Early in a new search, and again at the offer stage, we talk with hiring managers about what kind of salary they plan to offer the candidate. In those conversations, many hiring managers struggle to talk strategically about employee compensation. Fortunately, most experts agree on which factors you should consider. Before we get into the most effective way to set salary for a new hire, let’s dispense with the most common, but counterproductive, salary negotiation tactic: starting low.

Lead With Your Best, Not What You Hope They’ll Accept

Salary negotiation is a pivotal time in the hiring process. As an employer, it’s easy to forget that the candidate is not yet one of your employees. You can create or destroy trust and set the tone for the entire employment relationship by how skillfully you negotiate salary.

Job seekers have access to credible salary information and, with the rise in pay transparency, can see what other organizations pay for similar roles. You need to assume they know the market for their skills as well, or better, than the hiring manager.

Don’t intentionally present a low offer in hopes that the candidate will either take it or be willing to keep negotiating.

“The best use of money is to take the issue of money off the table . . . Effective organizations compensate people in amounts and in ways that allow individuals to mostly forget about compensation and instead focus on the work itself.”

— Author Dan Pink, Drive

Related Resource: Getting Clear About Pay: A Roadmap for Success in the Era of Transparency with Jenn Wendus of SmithPilot, Compensation Solutions for Nonprofits

Five-Factor Framework for Determining Salary

When determining salary, don’t rely on data from salary surveys alone. Salary surveys are valuable but only as a starting point. You need to look at data from multiple surveys and base your comparison on jobs that require the same competencies in the same functional area at organizations of a similar size and complexity. From, there adjust based on specifics related to your organization. Compensation and pay equity expert Kim Keating suggests using the five-factor framework below:

For example:

  • If the local supply of talent for a particular skill is scarce, you might need to pay at the 75th percentile of salaries in the survey.
  • If the local supply of people with a particular skill is abundant, you might only need to pay at the 40th percentile.
  • If your performance expectations for the position are exceptionally high (often with responsibility for major revenue drivers), you should consider paying at the 75th percentile.
  • If your performance expectations are typical, the 50th percentile might do.

In the executive search world, we operate almost exclusively at the intersection between a scarce supply of talent and exceptionally high performance expectations. But not all of our clients need to make salary offers at the 75th percentile.

To spend your salary budget wisely, you need to look at all five factors in combination. If you enjoy low turnover among your best people, and your industry has rock-solid stability while other local employers do not, you might find that paying less will work out just fine. Similarly, if your organization is highly regarded, and top performers are standing in line to work for you (that’s called “High Affiliation” on the chart), you might not need to pay top dollar.

Related Resource: How to Determine Fair (and Competitive) Compensation for New Hires

“You have to be very clear about the criteria that determine an individual’s pay. It doesn’t matter whether it is education, experience, performance, the size of the department, the department’s revenue responsibility, etc. But for a system to be perceived as fair, you have to articulate your organization’s key drivers for the internal pay hierarchy. You’re not going to get any return by paying people the same. If you say, ‘All Directors should be paid the same,’ regardless of performance, experience, etc., it ultimately demotivates your high performers. Instead, create consistent criteria for where an employee and their position fall in the salary range.”

— Kim Keating, former Founder & President of Keating Advisors Consulting

Keep Reading